Vania Phitidis
Written by Vania Phitidis
Peaceful Eating Coach
Last updated on 21 October 2024
Reading time: 9 minutes

Journal 3

Last week I wrote about the obstacles or resistances that are typical around food journalling. If you missed it, read it here. This week, I want to tell you why it can be a useful tool, and a few suggestions on how to use one. I also have a couple of versions you can experiment with, for you to download.

Why use a food journal?

In truth, it isn’t usually about the food anyway (unless you’re actually physically hungry), but it is through your relationship with food and your eating that you can learn so much about yourself. Using a food journal can support you to understand more about why you’re eating when you’re not hungry.

1. It supports mindfulness

If you do a fair bit of mindless eating, having the discipline to write it down will support your intention to become more mindful. This afternoon I was emptying a packet of raisins into a jar, and after I’d put the jar in the cupboard, I noticed there were still 3 raisins left in the packet. I popped them into my mouth without thinking. That was mindless eating. Not that there’s anything wrong with that, it’s really no big deal – but if I were journalling, I’d have got the journal out before eating and written it down. I’d have had the opportunity to check in with my hunger. I wasn’t hungry. And I would have asked myself why I wanted to eat the raisins, since I wasn’t hungry. I may still have eaten them, but at least that would have been conscious eating, and I much prefer to eat that way.

2. It supports curiosity

Your experience of a food journal will be largely dependent on your purpose for keeping one. If you have a purpose to become curious about your eating, as if you’re a scientist investigating your own life, then it’ll make journalling much more interesting and even fun. Imagine that! It’s like being an explorer, discovering unknown parts of yourself.

Curiosity is a strong desire to learn or know something. Here are some of the things journalling can help you find out:

On a physical level

  • How long different foods keep you satisfied
  • Which foods may be causing physical reactions
  • What different levels of hunger and fullness actually feel like in your body
  • How much food satisfies you at different levels of hunger

On a mental/emotional level

  • Which situations trigger your overeating
  • Which feelings trigger your overeating
  • Which disempowering thoughts drive you to food
  • And which empowering thoughts make it easier to use food for its primary purpose: to nourish your body

That’s pretty useful information don’t you think?

3. It supports decision making

When you journal, you create more of a space in which you decide about eating. If you remind yourself you have unconditional permission to eat whatever you want, you’re not trying to stop yourself, you’re just becoming curious about what you’re doing, and taking a pause (by journalling), you will be supporting yourself to make a conscious decision, rather than a knee-jerk one.

Conscious decisions, even if they are to eat when you’re not hungry, are empowering! At least you’re taking responsibility for your choice to eat; at least you know why you’re doing it… at the very least, you’ve given yourself an opportunity to explore. Many of these types of experiences will build up to you making more of the kinds of food decisions that will result in you becoming a peaceful eater.

Journalling will also support you to make eating decisions that serve your body. Because journalling really requires you to tune in to yourself, you’ll learn which foods feel good in your body and which don’t. I learned that raw cocoa really doesn’t do well in my body. I learned that pulses are fine in my body in small quantities, but I really don’t do well with them as a main meal. Some foods will make you feel energised, some lethargic, etc.

When you see your body’s reaction to foods with an attitude of curiosity and non-judgement, it’s so much easier to make a choice about eating them.

Pitfalls

1. Judging your food

One of the biggest pitfalls of seeing in writing what you’re putting into your mouth, is judging the food you’ve eaten.

To make the most out of food journalling, you really do need to have an attitude of curiosity and non-judgement. Judging your food as good or bad, too much or too little, will likely take you further away from tuning in to your body. Really, your body is your best guide as to what, when and how much to eat.

If you see that you’ve eaten lots of high-sugar and high-fat foods, you might make a decision not to eat again that day (or even the next) even though you’re hungry, or you might decide to eat under a certain number of calories; or choose foods that are lighter, or less food, not because that’s what you’re body’s asking for, but because your mind doesn’t approve of what you’ve eaten and wants to ‘rectify’ your decision.

If this happens, simply notice ‘I’m judging my consumption/ judging these foods as too much or the wrong foods’ and remind yourself: no food is good or bad; that you’re doing this to learn more about how you behave around food, and to empower yourself to gently change your behaviour.

2. Judging yourself

If you’re judging the food, you’re likely judging yourself as well, as a good or bad person, depending on what or how you’ve eaten. Again, gently remind yourself that you have unconditional permission to eat whatever you want! Food choices have nothing to do with who you are.

If you notice you’re judging yourself,  remind yourself of your intention to be kind and gentle. Drop the judgements like a hot potato.

How to journal

What’s your purpose?

As I said earlier, having a purpose to be curious about what you do with food, is the most helpful purpose to have in this situation.

Having a purpose to lose weight, or to control your eating will not end well! When you’re on your learning journey, and you begin to pay attention to your body, thoughts and feelings, you will slowly change your behaviour. Losing weight, if indeed your body is carrying more than it needs to, will happen as a natural consequence. Instead of having to ‘control’ your eating, you’ll be at ease with it, without a fight.

If your purpose is to become curious, then how you journal is with an attitude of curiosity. Asking yourself questions: I wonder why I ate 3 brownies after dinner? Was I being mindful? Did I enjoy them? How do I feel 20/30/90/120 minutes later?

Practically, you can use a notebook, your phone, a folder with loose sheets collected – anything that works for you! Be as creative or as simple as you like. Make it work for you.

What to journal

What do you want to learn about?

Decide what you want to know. If you want to know how long food sustains you, you need to know the time each time you eat. If you want to know how hungry you are when you eat, then you’ll need a column for your hunger level. If you want to know how much of the time you’re eating beyond satisfaction, then you’ll need to record that!

It can be helpful to know how you’re feeling when you eat, and what you’re thinking. Your actions are almost always in response to your emotions. And your emotions are generated in response to your thoughts – so these can be very useful to monitor (and challenge too, of course).

One thing that is often overlooked is to acknowledge whether you’ve enjoyed what you’ve eaten. Dieting and bingeing really take the enjoyment out of eating. There’s often so much guilt around eating certain foods; and let’s face it, diet foods can be pretty tasteless! Learning what you actually enjoy, once you’ve given yourself permission to enjoy it, is really fascinating! I learned I really don’t enjoy milk chocolate, unless it’s super-high quality (like handmade Swiss or Belgian), and in small amounts.

Then what?

The whole point of your journal is for you to be learning from it! So use it for that purpose. Make a time each week to look back over your journal and reflect. Look for patterns, look for times when you managed yourself in an empowered and conscious way and acknowledge yourself for that. And look for the places where you didn’t – what can you learn from those instances? What might be possible for you to choose to do differently another time? Close your eyes and imagine yourself doing that next time you get the opportunity.

Did you know that the brain doesn’t actually recognise the difference between your imagination and reality? Consciously imagining yourself behaving in the way you want to, does imprint on the brain. It’s like an actual experience, especially if you can bring as much sensory input to it as possible.

Here are a couple you can experiment with…

So, if I’ve convinced you to give it a try, here are a couple of templates you could experiment with. One is a very basic one, and the other has more information. Mix and match! Create your own based on what you want to know about your eating behaviour. You can also start with less information and build up. That’s often what I do with my clients.

You can sign up and download them here.

I’d love to know your experiences, where you’re finding it helpful and where you’re getting stuck. Please do let me know.

Much love to you, and happy exploring xx

With love from Vania